Discussion :: Statement and Argument
-
Directions : Each of the following question consists of a statement followed by three arguments I, II and III . You have to decide which of the arguments is a STRONG arguments and which is a WEAK Argument.
Statement : Is caste-based reservation policy in professional colleges justified?
Arguments :
I. Yes. The step is a must to bring the underprivileged at par with the privileged ones.
II. No. It obstructs the establishment of a classless society.
III. Yes. This will help the backward castes and classes of people to come out of the oppression of upper caste people.
|
A.
Only I and II are strong |
|
B.
Only II is strong |
|
C.
Only II and III are strong |
|
D.
Only I and III are strong |
|
E.
All are strong |
Whatsapp
Facebook
Answer : Option B
Explanation :
Clearly, capability is an essential criteria for a profession and reservation cannot ensure capable workers. So, neither I nor III holds strong. However, making one caste more privileged than the other through reservations would hinder the objectives of a classless society. So, argument II holds strong.
Be The First To Comment